The Best Email, Websites, Social Media, Content, Presentations In 2013: Others’ Reviews

For those of us susceptible to FOMO (Fear of Missing Out), year-end reviews are a tonic. They can catch us up, help us see an underlying order to what we’ve just lived through and provide some perspective on how to tackle the next year.

Rock The Boat Marketing is taking a two-post approach to putting a bow on 2013. On Monday, you’ll see RTB’s annual Content Highlights of the year. What follows is a compilation of what others have called out as noteworthy.

Email

Email is the mutual fund and exchange-traded fund (ETF) marketer’s workhorse—it’s what digital marketers do the most, email is interacted with the most and it produces the most results.

email

Every year at about this time, I regret that I haven’t paid more blog attention to email. As a Chicago Cubs fan, I take comfort in knowing that there’s always next year to atone (and note that I’ve started by listing email first in this post).

In the meantime, please check out this iMedia Connection post highlighting the innovative approaches your peers in other industries took with email in 2013. This industry could use some of that.

Websites

Everybody has been at it so long that lists of "best" Websites tend to have little turnover year after year. If you’re looking for fresh inspiration, check out this DailyTekk list of “the 100 Best, Most Interesting Blogs And Websites Of 2014.” Best enjoyed after hours and on a tablet.

Social Media

Such a big topic it would have been easy to go off the tracks—or run longer than two minutes—but Socialbakers does neither in this succinct summary of social media networks in 2013. 

Content

Those of us marketing thought leadership pieces have been slogging at it for years, but content marketing took on a life of its own this year.

So, it’s no surprise that year-end content marketing reviews got pretty meta. Example: 18 of the Best Content Marketing Strategy Guides of 2013 by Tom Pick of Business 2 Community. These will tide you over until the Rock The Boat Marketing Content Highlights post next week. 

Presentations

With an August publication date, this HubSpot post doesn’t have a year-end hook. No matter, 20 Inspiring SlideShare Presentations Every Marketer Should See is a valuable curation.

It’s also a way for me to call your attention to the Upworthy approach—hmm, what could you achieve if your team was required to write/test 25 headlines for every piece of content? For more background than what the presentation provides, also see this PDF.

 

See you Monday!

Saving The Best For Last—3 Terrific Asset Manager Videos To Close Out The Year

With several years of talking head experience behind them, many mutual fund and exchange-traded fund (ETF) firms are getting the knack of using video to engage, educate and even inspire.

From my perspective, these three videos released in the last four weeks or so are among the best of the year.

Required Viewing

Can you think of any other investment firm that regularly cautions investors to stay away from its products? 

If you cannot tolerate substantial losses in short periods of time stay away from leverage! http://t.co/zlW3CehqWJ

— Direxion Alts (@DirexionAlts) December 3, 2013

Given its leveraged and inverse fund offerings, DirexionShares is practically obligated to provide product education. But they’ve really risen to the occasion with an ambitious set of animated videos that break down what would otherwise be dry issues to have to slog through in text. A transcript and glossary are made available as accompanying pieces.

Double-digit views for all but the first video must be a disappointment. More prominence for the series on the site, including the home page, would lift its visibility.

Go to the landing page and not the individual YouTube video page to see the full presentation.

"We Love Great People"

This new BlackRock video in support of the GLAAD Ally Network initiative employs a lot of familiar devices used in videos—fast pace, multiple smiling faces, people holding signs.

What makes it different is that some of the faces belong to named, senior people at BlackRock. Including the Global Head of iShares, the General Counsel and the deputy chief operating officer adds gravitas. At a time when other firms in other industries are embracing "diversity as a competitive advantage," the video is one way of asserting what appears to be authentic leadership in this space.

The YouTube description explains that BlackRock was recently recognized as a "Best Place to Work for LGBT Equality" by the Human Rights Campaign. Because this video is about something so different than most BlackRock videos, I think it could have been launched with more context—maybe a landing page or a press release. This is not a recruiting video per se, but I could see BlackRock extending its life by adding the video to the firm's LinkedIn Careers page

The Animated Case For Diversification

Back in the day, all asset management marketers had was an efficient frontier chart to convince investors that they may want to diversify their U.S. domestic portfolios.

Franklin Templeton raises the bar with this video on home country bias, released in late November. The animation is entertaining but the story had to come first, and it’s in the storytelling where I think this video excels. It's the third in an Investor Education series introduced in late 2012. 

The December 12 RegEd Webinar with Blane Warrene and Susan Weiner, which I mentioned when I published this post last week, has been postponed. Watch for an update from RegEd.

Keep an eye out for RTB's annual Content Highlights of the year, to be published on Monday, December 16. This is a random, thoroughly subjective list that has no articulated criteria. (For example, see last year's post.) That notwithstanding, if you have a nomination, please post here or email me no later than Wednesday, December 11.

Fund Fact Sheets: The State of the Art

Mutual fund and exchange-traded fund (EF) digital marketers can and should make big plans. But everyone knows that the accurate, on-time publishing of quarterly fund fact sheets is Marketing Job #1 at asset management firms. Nothing gets done until the fact sheets are updated. It can be a life-sucking experience.

71650015b2debc21897b3f860fc22dd3.png

Because it’s been a while since I’ve been in the line of fire for this work, I asked Kurtosys to answer a few questions on the state of the art.

I became acquainted with Kurtosys, “a global provider of digital marketing and client reporting tools that help asset managers attract and retain investor assets,” via Twitter and I like their blog, too. Kurtosys is in the business of selling solutions and in the process of preparing this post it was sometimes impossible to de-couple their response from their philosophy and their underlying product. Still, I think their market perspective is worthwhile.

Beyond the relationship we established in our back and forth for this post, Rock The Boat Marketing has no business tie to Kurtosys. If another provider of fund fact sheet automation solutions wants to submit a guest post with answers to these same questions, I’d be happy to publish it, too. The more we can all share about who's doing what to get the fact sheet monkey off our backs, the more time we'll have to do value-added work.

The answers below were provided by Gerritt Graham (Commercial Director-Americas).

Q. What’s the standard today for how quickly and efficiently the majority of asset managers are producing fact sheets?

Gerritt Graham, Kurtosys

Gerritt Graham, Kurtosys

Graham: These days, we’re hearing that fact sheet production takes from one to three weeks or longer. Depending on the size of the asset management company, there’s a tipping point where automation becomes a necessity, and that usually happens when a firm manages 10 funds or more. Larger organizations that produce hundreds or thousands of fact sheets already have automation in place. In these cases, any edit to the system becomes a “Change Management” issue, and they typically work to continuously improve this process.

Q. Are firms waiting for the data for all funds to be available? Or, are they publishing on a staggered basis reflecting the fact that data for some funds can be available earlier than other types of funds?

Graham: Generally, all fund documents are produced simultaneously at month or quarter-end. More often, it’s staggered by delivery channel, which is a big problem. The asset manager’s Marketing team says, “OK, we have our fact sheets done and posted on the Web, now we have to key them into all of the Website’s charts and presentations!” 

Different organizations prioritize this differently. Some don’t even post data on the Website, but those that do are scrambling to do it in synchronicity with their PDF reports to clients, PowerPoint decks and other sales and marketing materials. And that’s no small trick, as this fund performance info can have multiple versions, domiciles, languages and document types for different devices.

We talk to our clients about keeping all data and documents in a unified data model (UDM) that enables the same fund performance info to flow through all distribution types. This takes a combination of two processes: 1) understanding and classifying all this financial data in a unified way and 2) mastering all of these output types: Websites, monthly or quarterly fact sheets, longer fund/strategy reviews, pitchbooks or sales aids, and increasingly, mobile applications. It’s essentially implementing one solution and delivering five kinds of output.

Q. The industry has had automated solutions for publishing fact sheets to print, PDF and Web for years now. What's the status of publishing to presentation decks?

Graham: Creating data-driven pitchbooks is a massive problem across the board. Asset management firms build automation to output PDFs and they don’t want to break it by moving to other output types like pitchbooks or presentations.

As a standard document, fact sheets usually come first—most firms have established calendar deadlines to publish these, so that’s the priority. Too often, any subsequent works based on those fact sheets are error-prone as the derived content is entered by hand and these manual processes introduce errors. We believe that the goal should be to automate the creation of pitchbooks or presentations, enabling dynamic updating as the underlying data changes.

Q. Are there other state-of-the-art applications? Are there any advances in Web delivery of fund marketing data? 

Graham: The truly disruptive game-changer is harnessing the analytics behind newer, interactive fund tools. Most fund marketers already understand how tracking the investor’s online journey can help you test and tune your Website to get significantly better marketing results.

But financial service marketers need to get beyond the basics of just knowing which pages are attracting the most visits. That won’t cut it when it’s time to justify exactly which fund marketing efforts make a difference. Tracking ROI with real marketing revenue means getting smarter about this. Meta tags on drill-down data like fund type, domicile and other identifiers can help asset managers turn Web traffic into actionable intelligence. That’s what’s happening now.

Q. Back in the day, the most difficult data requests tended to come from national account relationships. There was the case of a valued distribution partner that used a different categorization of our funds than we did. And, most firms used just a handful of funds versus the full range. The request was that we provide monthly and even daily updated data on just those select funds, using the partner’s asset class designations, to the firm’s Intranet or Extranet.

What’s happening today? Has anything changed in terms of how those one-off requests get handled?

Graham: The industry is so behind in using technology that issues like these are maddening for most asset managers. Firms can’t assume the position that “We deliver data just this way.” They should be looking at what their target investors and partners really want. That’s what stirs real innovation.

This market is report-centric. The first thing everyone asks about is output: “What do I need to show and how should it look?” The second step is to build a pipe to get the data.

As a result, everything is fit for one purpose. Every new classification, mapping or output type needs a new purpose-built solution (or it becomes a stapled, duct-taped mess). This approach isn’t scalable. We believe in unifying the data so changes like this simply become “Let’s turn on this switch,” and out comes another type of reporting. 

Q. The industry has extensive experience in feeding data to outside services (e.g., Morningstar and Lipper), but what can you tell us about distributing selected data (not every fund, not all data, etc.) to other applications—for example, a display ad with a data reference that must be updated?

Graham: We don’t hear a lot of questions about that currently. But there is a huge opportunity to inform the asset manager about all the places where their data appears—and where it’s wrong. Because of manual processes or unchecked data feeds, outside data services can end up showing incorrect data.

This happens today—from the fact sheet to the presentation to the asset manager’s own Website—with data that’s not just out of sync, but completely wrong! And you can imagine how your typical Chief Compliance Officer feels about this. An “entitled distribution” process can enable a firm to choose which information—at both the document and meta-data level—is permissioned to be sent to each recipient before it leaves the system.

Q. Finally, what are your smartest clients talking to you about?

Graham: Our most cutting-edge clients are thinking creatively with us about improving workflow, analytics and display technologies. But in the end they want to use technology to attract and retain assets. That means understanding the different needs of their audience, whether they are deep-pocketed and conservative institutional investors or their influential consultants or even individual investors who have increasingly high expectations for sexy, impressive presentations.

JPMorganUK.png

Check out [above] what JP Morgan UK is doing—beautiful layout and groundbreaking use of embedded data and performance charting. They’re doing the work of getting to know the audience, A/B testing interactive pages, and delivering the message in the appropriate way and channel.

Gerritt Graham is responsible for managing all sales, account management and long-term revenue strategy at Kurtosys in the Americas. His nearly 20-year financial services and technology career includes a variety of senior, global business development roles at The Oracle Corporation, Thomson Reuters and the Gerson Lehrman Group.

A Glimpse At What Goes On Behind Closed Doors

Today online, there’s no telling who’s going to share what about a business, taking advantage of low-barrier publishing capabilities and distribution via social networks.

The investment industry is taking part in this trend toward full disclosure (if you will), and that's quite a departure. When investment communications were bound by the physical distribution of printed materials, investors were provided with the bare minimum that was required and maybe a shareholder newsletter printed on tissue paper. The economics prohibited fund companies from going much further.

Now that peeks at the culture, capabilities and processes are being posted by investment firms, advisors, investors and others, the rest of us are gaining a better—albeit random—idea of what's going on behind your closed doors. 

Inside SEI

I actually laughed out loud when I saw this tweet from SEI yesterday. Desks on wheels as a brand proof point!

SEI's desks are on wheels to allow for easy collaborating. Check out @SEIRaefL on the move! pic.twitter.com/U5Ufj4fE3m

— SEI Advisor Network (@SEIAdvisors) November 12, 2013

This Meeting Is By Invitation Only But...

The notion of a closed meeting or conference call is falling by the wayside. Organizations including "the elite gathering of the nation's pre-eminent independent advisors" (#BarronsTopAdvisors) are announcing hashtags. And, even when tweeting from an event isn't fully sanctioned by the sponsor, at least one or two attendees more often than not will.

Today we’re welcoming 130 advisors to our Ascent 2013 conference. If attendees are tweeting, use #RussellAscent to share your thoughts!

— Russell Investments (@Russell_News) October 8, 2013

I am tweeting live from the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. Thank you to @OppFunds for making this happen.

— Steinberg Financial (@steinbergfinadv) September 13, 2012

Thrilled to be here @jpmorganfunds in NYC hearing about investment opps from 5 star mgr Clare Hart pic.twitter.com/j1zD5HMFOL

— Taylor Financial Grp (@TaylorFin_Group) September 18, 2013

Mike Malinsky with @JanusCapital teaching our advisors about the "Art of Wow". Janus Labs is good stuff! pic.twitter.com/IQwOI44Yxz

— Robert Johnson (@_RLJ) October 16, 2013

The Camera Doesn't Always Lie

The next example is not from the wild, the photo appeared with others in an ad campaign/microsite. What I love about it is its realism, even if it was directed realism.

This looks pretty faithful to how work gets done at MFS, across three screens in probably three locales. Nobody spruced up, nobody’s smiling, there’s no glamorizing the job whatsoever. 

What Would You Watch?

Fidelity wrote a smart hashtag to accompany this photo of "the largest plasma screen in the world." Note the 19 retweets and 12 favorites. 

David Keller says the largest plasma screen in the world is located in our chart room! #whatwouldyouwatchpic.twitter.com/beCR2ffuAO

— Fidelity Investments (@Fidelity) August 27, 2013

Can I Get A Witness?

Let’s wrap up this skip through the Rock The Boat Marketing scrapbook by looking at a few tweets sent by investors sharing details of their investment firm experience. The images they upload are designed to both elicit a response and appeal to the court of public opinion. Not shown in the embeds are the firms' responses.

Seeing this screen more than half the time when I access my accounts is not confidence @TRowePricepic.twitter.com/GY7Rkguw1w

— Davy Stevenson (@davystevenson) May 11, 2013

You have to agree @TC_Talks that this is a RIDICULOUS amount of mail to get in a month. pic.twitter.com/yjMUlDzPTA

— Nicole Jobst Smith (@njobst) October 14, 2013

I get the feeling @fidelity really wants me to accept electronic statements. #doesNotFeelLikeAChoicepic.twitter.com/tPfewNo21t

— Doug Selph (@dougselph) May 3, 2013

Is Financial Services Content Marketing The New Black?

Orange may be the new black in streaming video, but is financial services content marketing, and digital marketing in general, the new black online?

Probably not. But it does seem as if content marketing produced about financial services content marketing is in vogue lately.

When you toil in relative obscurity, as most mutual fund and exchange-traded fund (ETF) marketers (and those who support them on the outside) do, the spotlight can be jarring. The initial reaction may be giddiness that somebody is paying attention...and then there's unease, “Hmm, let's hope they’ve paid close enough attention to get this right.”

Most of what's being published is "right." Some of the reports include useful insights. What I object to are the sweeping generalizations, the reports that are lightly researched and/or derivative, and the errors. If this is financial services content marketers' day in the sun, I'd like to see the breakthrough work that's being done, including the creative and innovative solutions that are being identified, get acknowledged. 

Financial Services Trails And Often Fails...

In March, I took exception to the start of a Content Marketing Institute post that sized up the state of content marketing in the financial services industry this way:

…financial service providers often fail to build and execute dynamic content marketing programs. Instead, they frequently rely on tried-and-true, but far less creative, tactics. Cue the deluge of exceedingly dry white papers and webinars, and the direct mail magazines that often just wind up in the trash.

To be clear, the problem isn’t a lack of effort, and it’s certainly not a lack of high-quality content. Instead, it’s the way the industry seemingly operates under the misconception that its heavy regulatory burdens both preclude and exempt it from taking a creative approach to content. Remember, those regulations are predominantly focused on what’s being said, not the style and delivery of the message.

Another problem is a palpable anxiety about the unknown that clearly stifles innovation and discourages a clear point of view.

The absence of a point of view? Uh, no, that doesn't characterize 90% of the work I see. I felt that this was a narrowly informed assessment. It partly redeemed itself by singling out three examples of creativity from Putnam Investments (the Retirement Savings Challenge blog), Credit Suisse (The Financialist digital magazine) and SunLife Financial's BrighterLife Website.

Or Maybe Financial Services Is Pioneering...?

A few weeks ago, an entirely different sentiment was expressed.  

In what must be one of the least commented (1 comment) and shared Huffington Post posts ever (financial services marketing may not yet be a mainstream topic), a strategist from Contently.com on October 15 proclaimed: "Over the past few years, we've seen some of the biggest brand publishing success stories come from the financial industry and across the full spectrum of financial services.”

You can download the 26-page ebook Banking on Content: How the Finance Industry is Pioneering the New Marketing for Contently’s take featuring mostly U.S. examples from BlackRock, Prudential, Fidelity, Putnam (again with the Retirement Savings Challenge blog) and Credit Suisse (The Financialist again).

They lost me on page 4 with the statement: "…the industry has to contend with two major agencies that regulate their media use: the Financial Services Authority (FSA) and the Financial Industry Regulator Authority."

The FSA was a regulatory body in the UK abolished six months ago. It’s the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. And, there's no mention of the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC) or the SEC?

The Rise Of Digital Marketing In 2013?

It’s not unusual for marketing automation provider Marketo to publish ebooks focused on digital marketing and verticals. There’s “The State of Content Marketing & Social Media in the Medical & Fitness Industries” and “The Doctor Will See You Now: Lessons for Marketing in the Healthcare Industry.”

Marketing automation makes sense for many firms in this space and I know of implementations where it's adding value. My issue is limited to Marketo’s financial services ebook, which starts with the title: “Don't Get Left Behind: The Rise of Digital Marketing in Financial Services.”

According to the Financial Brand, 40% of financial marketers’ budgets was devoted to digital in 2013. In order to command that much of the budget this year, the rise of digital marketing would have been years ago.

I'll also push back on the assertion that “…financial institutions are holding themselves back by being unwilling to change with the times.” The statement appears on the same page as a bar chart that shows one of the top concerns in adopting digital marketing tactics is "inability to prove ROI." Seems like a legitimate concern, and one that's more on-point than willingness or unwillingness to change with the times.

You can download the report, which cites Credit Suisse (whose The Financialist is cited again), SunLife (BrighterLife again) and Allianz among others.

A Smarter Take

As I was wrapping up this post, I heard from someone who’s in the B2B content marketing business. Angela Long of Reputation Capital and I had talked several weeks ago, and she was following up with her whitepaper titled—wait for it—“Content Marketing for Financial Services.”

Although most of the content is directed to financial institutions, one of the case studies is about Putnam. I’d rank Putnam as one of the top content marketers in this space, and this pieces shows they have more to talk about than just their retirement blog.

There’s little to fault in this information-packed paper, which includes a few quotes from me. You can download it here.

Take It From Someone Who Does It

Ultimately, industry practitioners may be the most reliable source to turn to for an accurate, real-time look at how financial services digital marketing, including content and social tactics, is evolving.

Slowly, the investment strategists, money managers and product people are finding their public voices. I can't wait until CMO-types start getting out there, pointing to what they recognize as ground-breaking and promoting their own firms’ good work. This will help all around but most especially in recruiting the kinds of creative and innovative talent that mutual funds and ETFs need to go forward.

It’s from August, but here’s a best practice presentation from Augie Ray, Prudential’s Director of Social Media Strategy that I came across in a post published last week on Social Media Today.

How are financial services firms, including Vanguard, Fidelity, Ameriprise, USAA and Zurich, using social media to help resolve the trust gap? Ray provides excellent context and good examples.